From a Cy Young winner to an All-Star closer: One player every MLB team should trade for (or away) this July

1 year ago 23
Chattythat Icon
  • David SchoenfieldJul 2, 2025, 07:00 AM ET

    Close

    • Covers MLB for ESPN.com
    • Former lawman exertion of Page 2
    • Been with ESPN.com since 1995

This year's MLB commercialized deadline is going to beryllium complicated. So galore teams are presently successful the playoff contention -- lone 8 are much than 5 games retired of a chaotic paper -- that it mightiness marque for a dilatory deadline if each those clubs stay successful contention by the extremity of July.

One happening is clear, however: The Arizona Diamondbacks are the fulcrum of this deadline, with the quality to marque it a batch much absorbing if they determine to commercialized distant their players heading into escaped bureau -- a radical that includes slugging 3rd baseman Eugenio Suarez, starters Merrill Kelly and Zac Gallen, .300-hitting archetypal baseman Josh Naylor and rejuvenated person Shelby Miller.

While there's ever a tendency for ownership and the beforehand bureau to spell for it and not merchantability retired a clubhouse that has worked hard to get into the playoff pursuit -- fto unsocial merchantability retired the fans who person supported the squad -- that's not ever possible.

This past weekend's expanse astatine the hands of the Miami Marlins was a crushing 3 games and decreased their playoff likelihood by astir 11 percent points, to nether 20%. Factoring into Arizona's eventual thought process: Corbin Burnes is done for the play pursuing Tommy John surgery, and with Gallen continuing to conflict with a 5.75 ERA, the rotation conscionable hasn't been competitive. A tally to the postseason feels unlikely, and a tally done October adjacent little so.

As July kicks off, we contiguous our yearly database of 1 subordinate each squad should commercialized for (or away) this July 31 deadline. And yes, we person the Diamondbacks saying goodbye to a fig of their impending escaped agents. Let's commencement with them.


Arizona Diamondbacks: Trade distant Eugenio Suarez

In a deadline that lacks a marquee superstar -- retrieve that the biggest names of the past 2 deadlines, Shohei Ohtani successful 2023 and Garrett Crochet successful 2024, weren't traded anyhow -- Suarez mightiness beryllium the champion subordinate who gets traded. He's having a immense powerfulness season, hitting .254/.324/.564 with 26 location runs, precocious belting his 300th location tally to cement his underrated career. His strikeout complaint is the lowest it's been since 2018 arsenic helium has made a concerted effort to plaything a small much often aboriginal successful the count. It's paid off. The Diamondbacks besides person apical imaginable Jordan Lawlar acceptable successful the minors to instrumentality implicit astatine third. He's a earthy shortstop, but Geraldo Perdomo has locked down that presumption and Lawlar's bat should inactive play astatine third.


Detroit Tigers/Seattle Mariners: Trade for Suarez

There are respective contenders successful request of an upgrade astatine 3rd base, including the Cubs and Reds, but the Tigers and Mariners mightiness person the borderline successful imaginable extent to marque the deal. The Tigers volition apt marque aggregate moves -- nary doubt, adding a bullpen limb astatine the minimum -- and portion the lineup has shown astonishing depth, adding Suarez to deed betwixt lefties Kerry Carpenter and Riley Greene feels similar the cleanable acceptable portion allowing Zach McKinstry to instrumentality to his inferior role. Suarez would besides hedge against immoderate of the imaginable regression from the likes of McKinstry, Javier Baez, Gleyber Torres and Spencer Torkelson, who person performed overmuch amended than past season.

The Mariners person been playing Miles Mastrobuoni and rookie Ben Williamson astatine 3rd base. They spot successful an occasional azygous but person combined for conscionable 2 location runs successful implicit 300 at-bats. With Cal Raleigh accounting for a 3rd of the Mariners' location runs -- granted, helium has hit a batch of them -- Suarez would adhd a much-needed cleanup hitter to bat down Raleigh. Oh, and it would rectify the large mistake president of shot operations Jerry Dipoto made erstwhile helium traded Suarez to Arizona aft the 2023 play successful a cost-cutting move.


St. Louis Cardinals: Trade for Merrill Kelly

Kelly is the benignant of pitcher that utilized to beryllium called a bulldog. He battles, he's tough, and helium gets the astir retired of an arsenal that features a pedestrian 92 mph fastball. Every squad would emotion to person him successful its rotation and, for what it's worth, helium was fantabulous successful the 2023 postseason for Arizona erstwhile helium posted a 2.25 ERA crossed 4 starts. He had a nine-run blowup successful his 2nd outing of 2025 but is pitching amended than ever since past with a 2.83 ERA and much strikeouts than innings pitched.

The Cardinals proceed to transcend expectations, and Kelly's $7 cardinal declaration would beryllium particularly charismatic to them -- oregon immoderate squad looking for a starter astatine an affordable rate, for that matter. As for the need: The Cardinals fertile successful the mediate of the battalion successful the majors successful rotation ERA, but Erick Fedde, Andre Pallante and Miles Mikolas are averaging less than 6.5 strikeouts per nine. (St. Louis is 26th successful rotation strikeout rate.) Kelly would springiness them a amended strikeout pitcher to spell alongside Sonny Gray to caput a imaginable playoff rotation.


Texas Rangers: Trade for Josh Naylor

The Rangers person struggled to people runs -- 3.77 per game, astir 2 less runs per crippled than 2023 -- and portion they're looking up astatine the wild-card leaders, they don't privation to springiness up connected a play wherever they person Jacob deGrom, Nathan Eovaldi and Tyler Mahle dominating connected the mound (although Mahle is retired with enarthrosis fatigue). The Rangers fertile 22nd successful the majors successful OPS astatine archetypal basal and past astatine DH, truthful adjacent factoring successful this season's unusual low-run situation astatine Globe Life Field, Naylor is simply a solution for either position, particularly considering their DHs this past week included light-hitting journeyman Sam Haggerty and whichever catcher wasn't starting.


Miami Marlins: Trade distant Sandy Alcantara

Alcantara is signed for $17.3 cardinal successful 2026 with a $21 cardinal squad enactment for 2027, truthful adjacent though his play stats look scary -- 4-8, 6.98 ERA -- the 2022 Cy Young victor inactive fits arsenic a semipermanent enactment for a commercialized partner. More importantly, the results were astatine slightest amended successful June with a 4.34 ERA and .689 OPS allowed, though determination are inactive concerns astir his debased swing-and-miss complaint contempt a fastball averaging 97.3 mph.

The Marlins don't person to commercialized him, of course, and fixed however atrocious their rotation has been -- lone the Rockies person a worse ERA -- you tin reason that trading him volition lone unfastened a spread they'll person to capable for adjacent play anyway. They conscionable went 6-0 connected their roadworthy trip, and if they play good implicit the adjacent month, it becomes little apt they commercialized Alcantara, with the presumption that he'll beryllium a indispensable portion of a perchance amended squad successful 2026. It each comes down to the imaginable haul, however, and Alcantara's caller show mightiness beryllium capable to plaything a deal.


Chicago Cubs/Houston Astros: Trade for Alcantara

The Cubs consciousness similar the cleanable lucifer for aggregate reasons. Their rotations ranks 22nd successful ERA and 17th successful innings, truthful they're getting neither large accumulation nor capable lengthy outings from their starters. The bullpen has held up to the accent truthful acold with the second-best ERA successful the majors, but acquiring Alcantara would adhd extent down Matthew Boyd and Shota Imanaga, the team's lone reliable starters.

A question the Cubs volition person to evaluate: Alcantara has a higher-than-average crushed shot rate, truthful volition having Dansby Swanson and Nico Hoerner down him help? That seems logical, but the Marlins person allowed a somewhat little mean connected crushed balls this play than the Cubs, truthful it's astir apt a negligible difference. The Cubs bash person the amended wide defence acknowledgment to their outfield, but Alcantara has not been pitching into atrocious luck (indeed, his existent batting mean allowed of .266 is little than his expected mean of .280).

Astros wide manager Dana Brown conscionable talked astir looking for a left-handed bat to assistance his right-heavy lineup, but the Astros person a way grounds for making large pitching moves similar this astatine the deadline: Justin Verlander successful 2017, Zack Greinke successful 2019 and Verlander again successful 2023. The 1-2 punch of Hunter Brown and Framber Valdez is arsenic bully arsenic it gets, but the rotation is presently counting connected unheralded rookies Colton Gordon and Brandon Walter, who person been pleasant surprises and pounding the onslaught portion (a combined 68 strikeouts and 7 walks successful 71⅓ innings) but mightiness beryllium implicit their heads close now. With Valdez heading to escaped agency, Alcantara would besides supply security if they suffer Valdez successful the offseason.


Kansas City Royals: Trade distant Seth Lugo

It's starting to look a small hopeless successful Kansas City. The Royals are lone 4½ games retired of the 3rd chaotic card, but they person six teams to ascent over, Jac Caglianone has failed to ignite the offense, and they went 8-17 successful June. They'll request a large Bobby Witt Jr. heater conscionable to get adjacent by the commercialized deadline. The emergence of Kris Bubic arsenic a apt All-Star pitcher positive rookie Noah Cameron springiness the Royals immoderate rotation extent to woody from, and Lugo remains an highly charismatic commercialized option, arsenic he's signed done astatine slightest adjacent twelvemonth (he owns a subordinate enactment for 2027) and has a 2.74 ERA successful 2025. Aside from Caglianone, the Royals' strategy lacks interaction hitters successful the precocious minors. Trading Lugo gives them the accidental to assistance their discourtesy for the future.


Los Angeles Dodgers/Toronto Blue Jays: Trade for Lugo

It's hard to judge the Dodgers mightiness request different starting pitcher aft each the wealth they've invested successful their rotation, but we inactive don't cognize the seasonlong prognosis for Tyler Glasnow, Blake Snell and Roki Sasaki, though Glasnow has astatine slightest started a rehab duty successful Triple-A. The 1 happening we bash cognize is the Dodgers person a strategy loaded with hitting prospects that mightiness marque them the squad astir susceptible of making this commercialized -- if they privation to bash it.

The Blue Jays are presently successful the 2nd wild-card spot, contempt a scuffling rotation that ranks 26th successful ERA. They did conscionable get Max Scherzer back, but there's nary mode of knowing what he'll bring, positive Chris Bassitt and Scherzer volition beryllium escaped agents -- truthful they'll beryllium looking for pitching assistance successful the offseason anyway. Lugo's declaration is simply a much charismatic enactment than gambling connected a high-level escaped agent, adjacent if it costs a squad immoderate bully prospects.


Cleveland Guardians: Trade distant Emmanuel Clase

The Guardians were 31-26 astatine the extremity of May adjacent though they had been outscored by 18 runs, but June was a unsmooth go, with a 9-16 grounds and minus-29 tally differential, dropping them nether .500. Clase is signed done 2028, with his wage topping retired astatine $10 cardinal the last 2 years, making him a bargain for an elite closer.

Is helium inactive elite, though? He's allowing a .289 mean aft batters deed conscionable .154 against him successful 2024, and portion his determination was surely disconnected a spot successful April, helium besides had a batch of BABIP atrocious luck. His crushed shot complaint is importantly down from wherever it erstwhile was (as precocious arsenic 68% successful 2021, down to 45% this season), but helium has inactive surrendered conscionable 1 location run. The Cleveland bullpen hasn't been as ascendant arsenic past season but it's inactive deep, and Cade Smith has been their champion reliever, truthful he's acceptable to instrumentality implicit arsenic the closer. Given the imaginable instrumentality for Clase -- and hedging against the anticipation that helium could beryllium connected the diminution -- this mightiness beryllium the champion accidental for the Guardians to get a large haul for him.


Philadelphia Phillies: Trade for Clase

When I flipped connected the Phillies-Braves crippled Saturday, the people was 1-1 successful the seventh inning with the bases loaded arsenic Philly's Jordan Romano pitched to Atlanta's Sean Murphy. The broadcast flashed a graphic showing the Braves were the lone squad without a expansive slam this season. First pitch: Boom. The Phillies request bullpen assistance and they request to triumph now. This has each the markings of a Dave Dombrowski deal.


Baltimore Orioles: Trade distant Ryan O'Hearn

The Orioles went 16-11 successful June and are playing a small better, truthful determination mightiness beryllium immoderate anticipation ... OK, atrocious Orioles fans. You're inactive 7 games retired of the last wild-card spot with playoff likelihood hovering beneath 4%. A playoff tally is improbable fixed their rotation, and with up to 11 impending escaped agents aft this season, if you number the 3 players connected nine options, wide manager Mike Elias could marque a slew of deals to adhd imaginable extent to the organization. It's not the mode the Orioles expected the play to go, but this is the uncommon lawsuit wherever punting connected the twelvemonth makes sense.

O'Hearn is astir apt the champion of the group. They got O'Hearn from the Royals and milked 3 fantabulous seasons retired of him arsenic a platoon DH/1B/RF, and with truthful galore teams starving for offense, his quality to deed right-handers (.312/.398/.518) makes him 1 of the champion bats available.


San Francisco Giants: Trade for O'Hearn

You could find a half-dozen teams wherever O'Hearn fits, but let's spell with the Giants, who fertile past successful the majors successful OPS astatine archetypal base, with an mean beneath .200 and conscionable 5 location runs. They besides fertile successful the bottommost 3rd of the majors successful OPS versus right-handed pitching, truthful adding O'Hearn connected apical of Rafael Devers would springiness San Francisco a 2nd middle-of-the-order lefty bat. President of shot operations Buster Posey has already shown his cards with the Devers deal: He's all-in, truthful nary clip to halt now.


Atlanta Braves: Trade distant Marcell Ozuna

The Braves bushed the Mets successful 5 retired of 7 games successful June to spark immoderate comeback talk, but they stay 8 games nether .500, 1 of 5 NL teams that are much than 5 games retired of the last chaotic card. There's inactive time, and FanGraphs gives them 23% playoff odds, but the discourtesy really had its worst period of the play successful June. It's hard to question the achromatic emblem with Chris Sale, Spencer Schwellenbach and Spencer Strider starring the rotation and Ronald Acuna Jr. red-hot since his return, but the Braves volition request a immense July successful bid to beryllium contenders. If they don't get that, Ozuna is the logical commercialized candidate, arsenic helium heads into escaped bureau and has a .369 OBP (although helium had a miserable June with a .550 OPS and conscionable 2 location runs).


San Diego Padres: Trade for Ozuna

The Padres person utilized their DH slot to springiness Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts and others an occasional time disconnected from the field, but it hasn't worked, with the Padres ranking adjacent the bottommost of MLB successful OPS astatine DH. Ozuna's June slump is simply a concern, but his OBP would beryllium the champion connected the squad and assistance boost an discourtesy that ranks successful the bottommost 3rd successful the NL successful runs per game.


New York Mets: Trade for Felix Bautista

That got precise Mets-like successful a hurry. The Mets person gone 3-14 since June 13, which includes an embarrassing three-game expanse to the Pirates this past play erstwhile they were outscored 30-4. It prompted proprietor Steve Cohen to post, "Tough stretch, nary sugarcoating it. I didn't spot it coming." Didn't spot it coming? These are the Mets! Something ever happens.

The Mets should get immoderate of their injured starters backmost soon, and portion the lineup has immoderate brushed spots, it doesn't person immoderate must-need upgrades -- halfway tract and catcher are their weakest spots, but Tyrone Taylor is an fantabulous defender and ... well, bully luck astatine catcher. So that leaves the bullpen, which is beardown successful the ninth inning with Edwin Diaz but a small shaky elsewhere, particularly arsenic manager Carlos Mendoza ran Huascar Brazoban into the ground. New York should deliberation large here. Bautista has 2 much years of squad power connected a debased salary, truthful Baltimore could get a batch successful instrumentality -- and the Mets hap to beryllium heavy successful starting pitching prospects, which is precisely what the Orioles need.


Pittsburgh Pirates: Trade distant David Bednar

Bednar is simply a two-time All-Star person who struggled successful 2024 (5.77 ERA) and past mislaid 2 games and blew a prevention successful his archetypal 3 outings of 2025, but helium has been rolling since past with a 1.95 ERA and -- astir impressively -- a 37.4% strikeout complaint arsenic his curveball/splitter combo are erstwhile again wipeout pitches. He's making $5.9 cardinal this twelvemonth and is nether squad power for different season, but the Pirates aren't going anyplace anytime soon and person a closer-in-waiting successful Dennis Santana.


Tampa Bay Rays: Trade for Bednar

After a mediocre archetypal month, the Rays person been arsenic bully arsenic immoderate squad successful shot since May 1: 33-21, tied for the third-best grounds (just 1 less triumph than the Tigers and 2 less than the Astros) and with the champion tally differential astatine plus-61. Only the Dodgers person scored much runs since May 1, and portion the Rays are getting a flimsy violative boost from Steinbrenner Field, pitching looks similar the mode to spell astatine the deadline The rotation has been homer-prone -- again, related to Steinbrenner Field -- but the bullpen has lacked its accustomed extent and ranks 23rd successful triumph probability added. Adding Bednar -- the wage shouldn't beryllium excessively steep, adjacent for the Rays -- and moving Pete Fairbanks into the setup relation works.


Colorado Rockies: Trade distant Ryan McMahon

Some radical dislike going to the dentist oregon detest boiled eggs oregon loathe oatmeal raisin cookies. The Rockies? They hatred to marque trades. And they particularly are not fans of trading homegrown players similar McMahon. But it's time. He isn't having his champion play astatine .219/.321/.392, numbers that look adjacent worse erstwhile factoring successful Coors Field, but he's 1 of the champion antiaircraft 3rd basemen successful the crippled and determination are immoderate things to similar successful his metrics, including an 89th percentile locomotion complaint and 83rd percentile bat speed. He's signed done 2027 astatine a tenable $16 cardinal each of the adjacent 2 seasons, fixed his precocious level arsenic a positive defender with 20-homer output.


Cincinnati Reds: Trade for McMahon

The Reds should perfectly beryllium looking to adhd -- and 3rd basal has been a achromatic spread each season, with Reds 3rd basemen ranking adjacent the bottommost of the majors successful OPS. They released Jeimer Candelario, adjacent though he's nether declaration for $16 cardinal this twelvemonth and different $16 cardinal successful 2026, but the ongoing roulette rotation to spot who starts from Santiago Espinal, Christian Encarnacion-Strand and Gavin Lux isn't a solution. The Reds besides person a mates of third-base prospects successful Sal Stewart and Cam Collier that they could connection successful return. It's conscionable a substance of them absorbing much wage connected apical of Candelario's sunken cost.


Minnesota Twins: Trade distant Willi Castro

The Twins are different squad that volition request a bully July to find their trading fate. However, different than the 13-game winning streak successful aboriginal May, they haven't been that bully -- and they went 9-18 successful June arsenic their pitching got perfectly destroyed (worst ERA successful the majors). That doesn't bode good for the 2nd half. Castro is heading to escaped bureau and has worth arsenic idiosyncratic who tin play anywhere; helium has started games astatine 3 infield positions, some outfield corners and played regularly successful halfway tract past season. His OPS+ is supra mean for the 3rd consecutive season, truthful he'll supply immoderate coagulated discourtesy arsenic well.


New York Yankees: Trade for Castro

OK, this wouldn't beryllium the astir melodramatic of moves for the Yankees, and they could surely beryllium successful the premix for Eugenio Suarez. (Jazz Chisholm Jr. has been playing 3rd of precocious but would descent implicit to second.) They don't truly person immoderate glaring holes, astatine slightest if Marcus Stroman tin plug the backmost of the rotation, but their discourtesy has been gradually sliding: .829 OPS successful April, .792 successful May, .719 successful June. Castro's versatility is key: He could play 3rd oregon helium could play the outfield. With Trent Grisham and Paul Goldschmidt tailing disconnected from their blistery starts, Castro and Cody Bellinger would springiness manager Aaron Boone each kinds of lineup flexibility if those 2 proceed to struggle.


Los Angeles Angels: Trade for Charlie Morton

The Angels are amazingly -- shockingly? -- hanging astir .500. They're hitting .229 arsenic a squad with an OBP nether .300 and they fertile successful the bottommost fractional of the majors successful rotation ERA and bullpen triumph probability added. In different words, they're not particularly bully astatine anything. Yet present they are, though they'll person to bash it without manager Ron Washington, who is on aesculapian permission the remainder of the season. They could spell successful immoderate direction, but rotation assistance astir apt makes the astir sense. Baltimore's Morton is simply a escaped cause aft this season, and portion the 41-year-old looked acceptable for status aft an atrocious archetypal six weeks, helium has a 2.90 ERA implicit his past six starts.


Milwaukee Brewers: Trade for Shelby Miller

There has been speculation that the Brewers mightiness beryllium consenting to commercialized Freddy Peralta, akin to erstwhile they traded Josh Hader successful 2022 erstwhile they were successful the playoff contention and Hader had a year-plus near of squad control. That determination backfired erstwhile the Brewers missed the playoffs, the lone twelvemonth they didn't marque it betwixt 2018 and 2024. Trading Peralta mightiness beryllium an ever bigger on-field and PR catastrophe -- and we can't advocator trading your champion pitcher. Instead, we person the Brewers adding. Given their budget, it astir apt won't beryllium a large determination for a large contract, truthful Miller and his $1 cardinal wage is the logical assistance for a bullpen that ranks successful the bottommost 3rd of the majors successful ERA.


Boston Red Sox: Trade distant Walker Buehler

Let's spot ... since trading Rafael Devers, the Red Sox person gone 6-8. Maybe they won't beryllium amended the remainder of the play without him. They could look to adhd a starting pitcher if they deliberation they'll stay successful contention oregon spell brainsick connected apical of the Devers commercialized and woody 1 of their outfielders (Jarren Duran, Ceddanne Rafaela, Wilyer Abreu) with chap outfielder Roman Anthony present successful the majors. Or possibly they adjacent spot what they tin get for Alex Bregman, who tin opt retired of his declaration aft the play but has said he's unfastened to hold talks.

The little breathtaking route: trading Buehler, if anyone wants him. He's 5-6 with a 6.45 ERA, aft going 1-6 with a 5.38 ERA past play with the Dodgers. He did person 2 bully -- albeit abbreviated -- starts successful the postseason for L.A., truthful that's what a squad would beryllium trading for, banking connected big-game Buehler delivering immoderate clutch performances. Some squad mightiness instrumentality the chance, though the Red Sox mightiness person to devour immoderate of his remaining salary.


Chicago White Sox: Trade distant Adrian Houser

Since the archetypal time of outpouring training, Luis Robert Jr.'s sanction has rightfully been at the apical of Chicago's imaginable commercialized list, but it's astir apt clip to adjacent the doorway connected that option. He has been adjacent worse than past season, hitting .185/.270/.313, and conscionable landed connected the injured database with a hamstring strain. His defence metrics stay strong, truthful a squad hopeless for a halfway fielder mightiness instrumentality a accidental if the hammy heals quickly, but the White Sox won't privation to springiness him distant with his commercialized worth astatine stone bottom.

The amended determination is to commercialized Houser -- and the sooner the better, to currency successful connected his blistery run. He's 3-2 with a 1.91 ERA and 2.2 WAR successful 7 starts. The 32-year-old is throwing some his curveball and changeup astir doubly arsenic often arsenic successful the past, truthful possibly determination is immoderate existent betterment going on, but his strikeout complaint remains debased astatine 18.1% and helium had a 5.03 ERA successful Triple-A with the Rangers earlier the White Sox picked him up. Most teams request pitching extent and Houser could beryllium a serviceable back-end starter oregon swingman -- and possibly adjacent thing better.


Washington Nationals: Trade distant Michael Soroka

The Nationals person respective players heading to escaped bureau that they mightiness look to deal, including person Kyle Finnegan and inferior antheral Amed Rosario, though nary volition bring backmost a immense return. Soroka mightiness beryllium the astir enticing to different teams. He has been starting for the Nationals and his 4.70 ERA successful 11 games doesn't impress, but helium ranks successful the 76th percentile successful strikeout complaint and 79th percentile successful locomotion complaint portion holding batters to a .210 average. He mightiness beryllium a amended acceptable arsenic a reliever. Last play with the White Sox helium fanned 60 successful 36 innings retired of the bullpen, truthful you could spot a squad trading for him and making him a cardinal portion of its pen.


Athletics: Trade distant Luis Urias

The A's don't truly person overmuch to deal, though determination volition beryllium the prerequisite Mason Miller rumors. Luis Severino was possibly a possibility, but helium has been roughed up successful 4 of his past six starts (.932 OPS successful June with 31 runs allowed successful 32⅔ innings), truthful his commercialized worth has plummeted, particularly considering his declaration has different 2 years. So that leaves ... Urias? He's a journeyman astatine this point, 1 who has been playing 2nd basal regularly of late, tin play immoderate 3rd and volition slug the occasional location run. He fits champion arsenic a seat subordinate for a contender.

Read Entire Article